Skip To Content

Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography

The Cumulative Environmental Management Association (CEMA)partnered with the Oil Sands Research and Information Network (OSRIN) to create the new Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography, which includes documents relevant to the environmental management of oil sands development in Alberta. The majority of the documents focus on the mineable oil sands in the Athabasca deposit, though some documents relate to in-situ developments. This bibliography was last updated in November 2014.

Inventory studies of birds on and near crown lease number 17 Athabasca Tar Sands 1974

Year of Publication: 1975

Abstract:
An inventory study of water-associated birds occurring on and near the Syncrude Canada Ltd. Lease #17 in the Athabasca oil sands was conducted during the period of July 8 to November 15, 1974. Regular ground surveys were conducted of 30 water bodies on and near the lease, including lakes, ponds, the Athabasca River, roadside borrow pits, and shallow marshes created by clearing and water diversion on the Syncrude construction site. Detailed descriptions of the habitat characteristics of the water bodies were made, and the habitats that birds occupied were recorded during all surveys. Daily migration watches were conducted near the Athabasca River during the period from August 26 to November 15. Casual observations (those not made during surveys or watches) were recorded in an annotated list. The common and widely-distributed nesting species were the common loon, red-necked grebe, American wigeon, ringnecked duck, common goldeneye, bufflehead, sora, spotted sandpiper, lesser yellowlegs, eastern kingbird, red-winged blackbird, and common grackle. Local increases in the numbers of mallards, pintails, and green-winged teal in late summer indicated that the study area may have been used as a moulting area by these species. Large numbers of migrating Canada and white-fronted geese flew over the area without stopping during late August and September. Large numbers of migrating waterfowl, mainly scaup spp., mallards, and American coots stopped over on some of the lakes during September and October. Large numbers of migrating shorebirds were observed on the shallow marshes on the Syncrude site during July and August. Migrating water pipits, warblers, sparrows, blackbirds, Lapland longspurs, redpolls, and snow buntings were commonly observed during autumn. Migrating bald eagles were frequently observed during September. One observation of an adult and an immature whooping crane was made during October. The habitat preferences of the common species, or groups of closely related species, were examined quantitatively by means of Stepwise Multiple Discriminant Analysis (SMDA) and Stepwise Multiple Regression Analysis (SMRA). SMDA was used to identify those species which occupied similar and dissimilar habitats during the summer (July-August) and autumn (September- October). Comparisons of the differences between species during these two time periods indicated that there was a general reduction in habitat specificity during the autumn period. SMRA was used to determine the habitats that each common species or species group was associated with during the period from July to November. Some ecological problems that could result from the Syncrude development were discussed.

Investigating salt and naphthenic acids interactions in the toxicity of oil sands process water to freshwater invertebrates

Year of Publication: 2010

Abstract:
The hot water extraction process used to produce bitumens from oil sands produces a large volume of oil sands process water (OSPW) that contain elevated concentrations of naphthenic acids (NA) and salts. Many oil sands reclamation projects are proposing the use of OSPW as part of reconstructed wetlands projects. This study investigated the toxicity of OSPW to freshwater invertebrates. The toxic interactions between NA and salinity on freshwater invertebrates were assessed. Bioassays with laboratory-cultured Ceriodaphnia dubia were conducted to determine the toxicity of OSPW from selected water bodies. The study showed that while the concentrations of NAs and salinity were elevated in OSPW waters that caused toxic responses, the concentrations of salinity ions varied greatly among the OSPW samples. Results of the study suggested that ion composition may be a factor in toxicity. Interactions between NAs and salinity were then assessed by performing bioassays with mixtures representing major ion combinations in OSPW.

Investigating the phytotoxicity of oil sands tailings water formed during atmospheric fines drying processing

Authors Cutter, J. L.
Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
Oil sands operators are being faced with the challenge of reclaiming the large volumes of slurry tailings created during oil sands processing. New regulations mandate that operators must minimize fluid tailings by capturing fines in dedicated disposal areas, leading to a ‘trafficable’ or solid deposit. Adding a polyacrylamide polymer to the tailings and thinly spreading them over a sloped disposal area (a process developed by Shell Canada Energy known as the atmospheric fines drying or AFD process) has been shown to enhance the dewatering of tailings which leads to a dry deposit at a much faster rate than traditional methods. Hydroponic experiments using the emergent aquatic macrophytes cattail (Typha latifolia L.) and common reed (Phragmites australis (Cav.) Trin. ex Steud.) were conducted to investigate the phytotoxicity of waters formed during AFD processing. The phytotoxicity of AFD release waters was compared to the phytotoxicity of traditional mature fine tailings (MFT) reclaim water through the monitoring of plant water uptake and whole plant fresh weight over the course of the experiment. It was found that there are no significant differences between the phytotoxicity observed in the MFT and AFD treatments and it was also found that spring runoff melt water from the AFD deposits is less phytotoxic than the original release water. Two additional hydroponic studies using cattail and common reed were also conducted. The first examined the phytotoxic effects attributable solely to the naphthenic acids isolated from Shell’s Muskeg River Mine tailings, and the second evaluated the phytotoxic effects of amending mature fine tailings with gypsum. It was found that the gypsum amended tailings caused greater phytotoxicity in cattail and common reed than tailings without gypsum added. Furthermore, both species were tolerant to growing in nutrient media spiked with naphthenic acids (40 mg/L). The phytotoxicity experiments conducted also demonstrated that common reed is consistently more tolerant to growing in water associated with oil sands tailings and is therefore the more appropriate choice for use in reclamation strategies involving wetland plants. Mass spectrometry was used to determine the naphthenic acid molecular profiles for Shell oil sands tailings. Using low resolution mass spectrometry, no detectable features or changes to the composition of naphthenic acids attributable to Shell processing were found. High-resolution mass spectrometry provided insight into possible plant mediated changes and biodegradation of naphthenic acids. It appears as though, to some extent, cattail is able to dissipate naphthenic acids, which could explain the susceptibility of cattail to the phytotoxic effects of naphthenic acids. Further research is required to determine whether the changes observed in the naphthenic acid mixture are due to microbial degradation and/or a phytotoxic response of the plants studied.

Investigation of CT beneath MFT deposition for oil sands tailings disposal

Authors Luo, G.
Year of Publication: 2004

Abstract:
The oil sands industry has implemented CT (Composite or Consolidated Tailings) process to manage the fine tailings produced during extraction. The co-disposal approach using CT placed beneath MFT (mature fine tailings) was proposed to improve the CT release water quality and the solids densification rates of both CT and MFT. This research used laboratory-scale static column mesocosms to study the physical, chemical, and microbiological changes occurring over time in this CT beneath MFT deposition. The results were compared to those in the control systems. The study showed that, over 1 year of incubation, the release water composition had been altered by reduction in the concentrations of calcium and sulphate ions, and the electrical conductivity; the MFT had steady densification rate; and the CT had a densification rate comparable to the control system. These results indicate that the CT beneath MFT deposition may be a beneficial disposal scheme for oil sands tailings management.

Investigation of microbial community response during oil sands reclamation via lipid and carbon isotope analyses

Authors Bradford, L. M.
Year of Publication: 2014

Abstract:
In this study, phospholipid fatty acids (PLFA) and carbon isotopes were used to characterize the response of in situ microbial communities to a pilot-scale wetland reclamation project in the Alberta oil sands, and to investigate their role in carbon cycling at the reclamation site. The Sandhill Fen reclamation project in the Athabasca oil sands region (Fort McMurray, Alberta, Canada) has created an artificial freshwater fen typical of the boreal forest region in which the oil sands occur. At this site, composite tailings (CT) residue was overlain with a thick sand cap and a freshwater fen constructed on top. Biomass in the peat material of the fen was comparable to that found in natural fens, and a comparison of PLFA profiles in peat, CT from a nearby site, and undisturbed wetlands in the area showed that microbial communities in Sandhill fen were more similar to those in the CT than those in undisturbed wetlands. Bacteria dominated the biomass, including a small percentage of sulphate reducing bacteria that are of particular interest in the reclamation project. Fungi and other eukaryotes were also present. Analyses of radiocarbon in total organic carbon (TOC) and residue from solvent extraction suggest that there was petroleum present in the peat layer of the fen. A small amount of young carbon from the fen surface has been transported into the CT layer in the form of dissolved organic carbon. Radiocarbon also showed that microbes preferentially metabolized more modern carbon within the carbon sources available to them. Biomass was more related to the age of carbon in the samples than to the TOC concentration, with younger carbon in the peat associated with higher PLFA concentration.

Investigation of water repellency and critical water content in undisturbed and reclaimed soils from the Athabasca oil sands region of Alberta Canada

Authors Hunter, A.
Year of Publication: 2011

Abstract:
Ecosystems are disturbed to extract synthetic crude oil from the Athabasca Oil Sands Region (AOSR) in northern Alberta, Canada. Successful reclamation of mined oil sands sites depends on maximizing water storage and minimizing the potential for erosion. Soil water repellency in the AOSR affects undisturbed sites and consequently reclamation materials. Extreme water repellency may lead to low infiltration rates and hinder reclamation. There is a lack of information about the naturally occurring and pre-existing levels of soil water repellency in the AOSR. Thus, questions arise about the degree of naturally occurring water repellency and the potential for severe water repellency in reclamation soils. Studies were conducted on nine sites in the AOSR in the summers of 2008 and 2009. A range of undisturbed and reclaimed sites, as well as mineral and organic reclamation materials were examined. Five undisturbed Jack Pine stands (classified as A ecosites), four reclaimed sites and reclamation materials including mineral soil, peat and leaf and lichen covering the forest floor (LFH) were studied. For a comparison of methods, one grasslands site in central Saskatchewan was included. Mini and standard tension infiltrometers were compared as a means of measuring soil water repellency index (RI). There was strong variability in RI values between the infiltrometer methods. The mean RI values from the mini infiltrometers were higher than from the standard infiltrometer (9.61 and 3.46, respectively). The variability within sites dominated the variability in RI for the two methods. Despite these obvious trends, RI values between infiltrometer sizes were statistically different for only two individual sites. Increasing the number of sampling points in the second field season did not reduce the variability. The simpler, less expensive mini infiltrometer is as effective as the standard infiltrometer in measuring soil water repellency. This will enable more efficient and extensive monitoring of soil water repellency in reclaimed and undisturbed sites in the AOSR. Soil water repellency of reclaimed and undisturbed sites was investigated in situ using RI, the water droplet penetration time (WDPT) test, and the molarity of ethanol droplet (MED) test. These measures showed similar trends. Variability in soil water repellency was high at both reclaimed and undisturbed sites. The average RI value for the surface of reclaimed sites was higher than that of the subsurface at reclaimed sites; however, there were no statistical differences between RI values of surface reclaimed and undisturbed sites (P =0.213) due to high spatial variability. The critical water content (CWC) of reclamation materials was determined by measuring the contact angle (CA) and WDPT. Generally, CA and WDPT were inversely related to water content, though variability was high and the relationship between water content was weak. The clearest relationship between water repellency and water content was present for the mineral soil samples. Reclaimed mineral soil was generally wettable above gravimetric water contents of 5- 10 %, while the coarse textured tarball affected materials were only subcritically water repellent. There was no relationship between water repellency and water content for peat and LFH. The degree of water repellency was statistically higher for peat materials with increasing decomposition levels. The average WDPT was 44, 128 and 217 s for fibric, mesic, and humic peat, respectively. With careful management and monitoring, water repellency may not be a major limitation to reclamation success. The mini tension infiltrometer is an effective method for monitoring soil water repellency in the AOSR.

Investigations of mercury concentrations in walleye and other fish in the Athabasca River ecosystem with increasing oil sands developments

Authors Evans, M. S., & Talbot A.
Year of Publication: 2012

Abstract:
Recent studies have reported an increasing trend of mercury concentrations in walleye (Sander vitreus) from the Athabasca River, north eastern Alberta (Canada); these studies were based on three years of comparison and attributed the mercury increase to expanding oil sands developments in the region. In order to conduct a more comprehensive analysis of mercury trends in fish, we compiled an extensive database for walleye, lake whitefish (Coregonus clupeaformis), northern pike (Esox lucius) and lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush) using all available data obtained from provincial, federal, and industry-funded monitoring and other programs. Evidence for increasing trends in mercury concentrations were examined for each species by location and year also considering fish weight and length. In the immediate oil sands area of the Athabasca River, mercury concentrations decreased (p < 0.001) in walleye and lake whitefish over 1984–2011. In western Lake Athabasca and its delta, mercury concentrations decreased (p < 0.0001) in northern pike (1981–2009) although no trend was evident for walleye (1981–2005) and lake trout (1978–2009). Mercury concentrations in lake trout from Namur Lake, a small lake west of the oil sands area, were higher in 2007 than 2000 (p < 0.0001); it is difficult to ascribe this increase to an oil sands impact because similar increases in mercury concentrations have been observed in lake trout from similar sized lakes in the Northwest Territories. While mercury emissions rates have increased with oil sands development and the landscape become more disturbed, mercury concentrations remained low in water and sediments in the Athabasca River and its tributaries and similar to concentrations observed outside the development areas and in earlier decades. Our fish database was assembled from a series of studies that differed in study purpose, design, and analytical methods. Future monitoring programs investigating mercury trends in fish should be more rigorous in their design.

Investigations of poly-chlorinated biphenyls in bottom sediments of the Bear-Wapiti-Smoky-Peace and Upper Athabasca River systems, 1989-2000

Year of Publication: 2004

Abstract:
Studies of contaminant distributions by the Northern River Basins Study (NRBS) revealed high levels of PCBs in fish in the upper Athabasca and in the Wapiti-Smoky rivers, relative to other areas in the basins. In response to recommendations of the NRBS, the purpose of this work was to investigate the source and reasons for the PCB contamination. In co-ordination with other projects under the Northern Rivers Ecosystem Initiative (NREI) on fish, water, and benthos, this project investigated PCBs in river bottom sediments to see if there were spatial or temporal patterns that might identify the source(s) of contamination.

Investigations of streambed oxygen demand, Athabasca River, October 1994 to March, 1995

Authors Noton, L. R.
Year of Publication: 1996

Abstract:
Presents findings of a project conducted to determine whether streambed oxygen demand (SOD) rates in the Athabasca River are consistently higher downstream of effluent inputs during winter, how the trend varies throughout the winter, and whether SOD is influenced directly by nutrient loads from effluents. Investigators obtained SOD measurements at 13 locations from upstream of Hinton downstream to the Calling River. The substrates at these locations were mainly coarse, with pebble, cobble, and boulder predominating. Controlling factors affecting SOD are discussed

Investigations of the spring spawning fish populations in the Athabasca and Clearwater Rivers upstream from Fort McMurray: Volume I

Year of Publication: 1979

Abstract:
Fisheries investigations were undertaken in the spring of 1978 (28 April to 25 June) in the Athabasca and Clearwater rivers upstream of Fort McMurray. The major objectives of the studies were to determine what spring spawners utilized these sections of the Athabasca and Clearwater rivers; to locate and describe their spawning grounds; and to describe the timing of spawning, hatching, and emergence in relation to environmental factors such as water temperature, turbidity, dissolved oxygen concentrations, and stream flow. Large numbers of longnose suckers spawned during mid May in the Athabasca River from Fort McMurray upstream to the Cascade Rapids, the same area used by fall spawning lake whitefish. The major concentrations were located just below the Mountain and Cascade rapids. There was no evidence of major spawning concentrations of this species elsewhere in the present study area. Shortly after spawning, longnose suckers left the project study area and presumably returned to the Peace-Athabasca Delta. Northern pike and burbot spawning and rearing areas were identified in the Clearwater River upstream of its junction with the Christina River. There was little or no spawning by either species in the Clearwater River downstream of the Christina River or in the Athabasca River upstream of Fort McMurray. No major concentrations of spawning walleye were located. However, based on the distribution of young-of-the-year, it appears that at least some walleye spawned at various localities in the Athabasca River from the Mountain Rapids to as far upstream as the Grand Rapids. There is no evidence that walleye spawned in the Clearwater River within the AOSERP study area. Lake whitefish young-of-the-year probably emerged and moved downstream out of the present study area before spring breakup. Longnose sucker young-of-the-year emerged at the beginning of June followed by pike, walleye, and white sucker young-of-the year later in June. The Athabasca River, and to a lesser extent the Clearwater River, provide valuable habitat for a number of minor species including flathead chub, longnose dace, and lake chub. Large numbers of juvenile goldeye also use the area as feeding grounds during the open-water period.

Investing in our future: Responding to the rapid growth of oil sands development. Final report

Authors
Year of Publication: 2006

Abstract:
To address the current challenges resulting from the rapid pace of oil sands development, and to anticipate the impacts of continuing growth, the Oil Sands Ministerial Strategy Committee was directed by Cabinet to develop a coordinated shortterm action plan to address the social, environmental and economic impacts of oil sands developments.

Is biodegradation of bitumen a source of recalcitrant naphthenic acid mixtures in oil sands tailing pond waters?

Year of Publication: 2005

Abstract:
Carboxylic acids are transient metabolites during the mineralization of petroleum hydrocarbons. Crude oils, however, vary in their proportion of the hydrocarbon components. Depending on structure, some carboxylic acid metabolites resist further biodegradation and persist in aquatic systems. During the extraction of oil sands bitumen, recalcitrant carboxylic acid mixtures, collectively referred to as naphthenic acids (NAs), are released into the wastewaters. These waters also contain unrecovered bitumen from the oil sands. The unextracted bitumen is often overlooked as a possible source of the petroleum acids. The present article discusses the literature data on the biotransformation of hydrocarbons in bitumen from oil sands to the corresponding petroleum carboxylic acids. Some insight is given on the mechanism of the biodegradation process. The susceptibility to biodegradation is affected by differences in alicyclic carboxylic acids such as carbon chain length, chain branching, and the oddness or evenness of carbon chain containing the carboxylic group, positions where alkyl groups are substituted on the cyclic ring, geometrical isomerism, and number of cyclic rings.

Isolation and characterization of humic acids from Alberta oil sands and related materials

Year of Publication: 1990

Abstract:
Thirteen humic acid samples were isolated from a number of oil sand feedstocks using 0.5 N NaOH or a mixture of 0.1 N NaOH + 0.1 M Na4P2O7. The feedstocks included three different grades of Athabasca oil sand, two samples of overburden, a sample of centrifuge tailings from the Syncrude Canada Ltd plant in Alberta and a heavy minerals fraction from oil sand tailings containing adsorbed organic matter. Based on the extraction efficiency of the two solvents it appears that the humic acids from oil sand and overburden feedstocks are strongly associated with calcium, while the humic acids from other feedstocks could be bound to non-silicate aluminum and/or iron. Comparison of analytical data for the various humic acid samples with corresponding data for humic acids from subbituminous coal, peat, soil and asphaltenes from bituminous feedstock, shows the similarity of these humic acids to those from subbituminous coal. Examination of the elemental analyses in terms of a van Krevelen diagram shows that most of the data either overlap or fall directly in the region of the recent and shallow kerogens. This kind of organic matter has very little potential for oil production, suggesting that the origin of this organic matter could be different from that of the greater part of the bitumen of the Athabasca oil sands.

Isolation and characterization of naphthenic acids from Athabasca oil sands tailings pond water

Year of Publication: 2002

Abstract:
A laboratory bench procedure was developed to efficiently extract naphthenic acids from bulk volumes of Athabasca oil sands tailings pond water (TPW) for use in mammalian oral toxicity testing. This solvent-based procedure involved low solvent losses and a good extraction yield with low levels of impurities. Importantly, labour-intensive centrifugation of source water to remove solids was avoided, allowing processing of much larger volumes of water compared with previous protocols. Naphthenic acids, present at an estimated concentration of 81 mg/l, were procured from 515.5 l of TPW at an overall extraction efficiency of approximately 85%. By using distillation to recover and recycle solvent, a high solvent:water ratio was maintained while actual solvent consumption was limited to 70 ml per liter of water processed. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry suggested a highly heterogeneous naphthenic acid mixture that exhibited nearly identical proportions of monocyclic, polycyclic, and acyclic acids with molecular weights primarily between 220 and 360. Biphenyls, naphthalenes, and phenanthrene/anthracene were the most prominent impurities detected, but their levels were low (⩽13 μg/l) even in a concentrated solution of the naphthenic acids (8549 mg/l). Naphthenic acids stored at 4 °C at this concentration were stable, exhibiting no significant change in concentration over a 10-month period. This bulk isolation procedure should be useful to others needing to process large volumes of tailings or other source water for the purpose of procuring moderate amounts of naphthenic acids.

Enter keywords or search terms and press Search

Search this site


Subscribe to the site

Syndicate content

Bookmark and Share