Skip To Content

Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography

The Cumulative Environmental Management Association (CEMA)partnered with the Oil Sands Research and Information Network (OSRIN) to create the new Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography, which includes documents relevant to the environmental management of oil sands development in Alberta. The majority of the documents focus on the mineable oil sands in the Athabasca deposit, though some documents relate to in-situ developments. This bibliography was last updated in November 2014.

Setting reclamation targets and evaluating progress: Submersed aquatic vegetation in natural and post-oil sands mining wetlands in Alberta, Canada

Year of Publication: 2011

Abstract:
Oil sands mining disturbs thousands of hectares of boreal landscape, about 65% of which is wetland. Its reclamation will constitute the largest wetland reclamation project in Canadian history. We developed a unified analytical framework that we used to set reclamation targets and evaluate reclamation progress using submersed aquatic vegetation (SAV). We sampled SAV in 38 minimally disturbed wetlands to establish a reference condition and compared this to SAV in 25 reclamation wetlands. We observed 26 taxa: all were native and five are regionally rare. Using a combination of ordination, clustering, and indicator species analysis, we identified seven SAV assemblages, distinguishable based on 10 indicator species. The assemblages found in wetlands contaminated by tailings had significantly fewer taxa. Using joint plots, we demonstrate that they differ in terms of environmental variables reflecting depth, slope, salinity, transparency, water and sediment nutrient levels, and alkalinity. Collectively, 74% of reference wetlands had SAV belonging to either marsh or fen–marsh assemblages that we consider suitable targets for reclamation. Having multiple reclamation targets avoids creating a homogenous post-mining landscape with low gamma diversity. Using complementary multivariate and categorical tests, we found that reclamation wetlands failed to support either of these dominant reference assemblages. Instead, every reclamation wetland supported one of five atypical SAV assemblages, each of which was uncommon (<10%) among reference wetlands. The analytical framework we developed can be applied to other ecosystems or taxa to develop targets for reclamation, to evaluate reclamation progress, and to identify environmental characteristics associated with reclamation targets.

Should Alberta upgrade oil sands bitumen? An integrated life cycle framework to evaluate energy systems investment tradeoffs

Year of Publication: 2011

Abstract:
The inclusion of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions costs in energy systems decision- making requires the development of a framework to inform stakeholders of the full costs and benefits of potential investments. This thesis develops such a framework by integrating life cycle assessment (LCA) with cost-benefit analysis (CBA) to explore the GHG and economic tradeoffs involved in upgrading vs. diluting oil sands bitumen under proposed carbon-price policies. An LCA study of these pathways is conducted through the development of a well-to-tank (WTT) spreadsheet model based on engineering principles and industry data. Plausible ranges of GHG emissions are developed for these pathways to explore GHG reduction opportunities. A CBA is then conducted to explore the costs and benefits of upgrading and dilution investments from multiple stakeholder perspectives. This thesis finds that at stringent carbon prices (> $75/tonne CO2e), public and private stakeholders may diverge in their views on whether Alberta should upgrade bitumen.

Shrub species review for boreal ecosite re-establishment in the oil sands region

Authors Corp., G. D.
Year of Publication: 2002

Abstract:
The Guidelines for Reclamation to Forest Vegetation have been scheduled to undergo a substantive review beginning in 2003 by the Soil and Vegetation Working Group (SVWG). At that time, information gathered will be used to make guideline revisions and to direct further research into the feasibility of recreating ecosites on reclaimed oil sands. This project is in response to the SVSG's request to evaluate the shrub species listed in the guidelines and make deletions or additions as required.

Simulation of soil water content on a small reclaimed watershed in northern Alberta using the Root Zone Water Quality Model (RZQWM)

Year of Publication: 2006

Abstract:
A study was conducted at Syncrude Canada Ltd., Alberta, to evaluate the simulation of soil volumetric water content from the reclaimed slopes of the Southwest Sand Storage Facility using the Root Zone Water Quality Model (RZWQM). Soil water content measurements were conducted every 2 wk using a neutron moisture meter in 2001 (dry year) and 2002 (wet year). Two types of calibration and evaluation were performed: first, calibration using 2001 weather data (dry year) and evaluation using 2002 weather data (wet year) (herein referred to as method 1); second, calibration using 2002 weather data (wet year) and evaluation using 2001 weather data (dry year) herein referred to as (method 2). Results from the method 1 calibration for each tube indicated modeling efficiencies (EF) between −0.27 and 0.90, coefficients of determination (r2) between 0.13 and 0.97, and deviation (D, as %) of simulated from measured values of less than 5%. The model evaluation by tube location following method 1 calibration indicated EF values between −3.80 and 0.56, whereas r2 values ranged between 0.08 and 0.82. Although five out of eight tubes had D values > 5%, all except for one tube had D values < 20%. Method 2 calibration results for each tube indicated EF values of −0.34 to 0.85, r2 values of 0.07 to 0.85 and all D values < 5%. Results of the method 2 model evaluation by tube location indicated EF values of −10.15 to 0.75 (overall EF = −0.84), r2 values of 0.04 to 0.96 (overall r2 = 0.39) and D values of 2.6 to 48.6% (overall D = 19.8). Method 2 model evaluation results indicated EF values of −1.69, −3.85 and −0.01, for depths of 15, 25 and 35 cm, respectively. The D values were 27, 20 and 13%, respectively. Graphical displays indicated that during the evaluation process, the model generally tended to slightly under-estimate the wetter moisture conditions, regardless of whether data for a wet year or a dry year were used during the calibration process. Key words: Modeling, calibration method, soil water, land reclamation

Simulation of the hydrological processes on reconstructed watersheds using system dynamics

Year of Publication: 2007

Abstract:
Reconstruction of disturbed watersheds is a common practice by the oil sands industry in northern Alberta, Canada. The reconstruction and restoration of the watershed hydrology are required as part of the reclamation mandated by Alberta Environment for mine closure. Assessment of the hydrological performance of the reconstructed watersheds is essential to ensure a sustainable reclamation strategy. A conceptual lumped system dynamics watershed (SDW) model is developed and calibrated in this study. The model, built within an object-based simulation environment, is capable of simulating the various hydrological processes in the reconstructed watersheds with good accuracy. STELLA Software is used as an object-based simulation environment that allows visual computations. The SDW model developed combines both physically-based and empirical formulations to replicate the hydrological system mathematically. The system dynamics approach along with the visual simulation environment help in developing a simulation-for-learning model, not only simulation for prediction. The model is successfully calibrated and validated; the results show that the SDW model is capable of simulating the various hydrological processes (soil moisture, evapotranspiration and runoff) with good accuracy. The SDW model can help in the assessment of the short- and long-term performances of the reconstructed watersheds, thus providing a useful decision-aid tool for the mining industry.

Site-specific industrial tracer application to the petroleum industry. Final report

Authors Main, C., & Jones D.
Year of Publication: 2014

Abstract:
This review presents a summary of tracers use in environmental applications and the potential for tracer use in the Athabasca oil sands. An extensive literature search was conducted accessing articles in refereed journals, theses and unpublished studies conducted by AITF.

Size distribution and transport of suspended particles Athabasca River February and September 1993

Year of Publication: 1995

Abstract:
This project was carried out for the Northern River Basins Study (NRBS) to characterize the size distribution and the transport processes of suspended particles in the Athabasca River below the Weldwood Pulp Mill outfall at Hinton. The project consisted of two field surveys: one, during the winter of 1993 and the other during the fall of the same year. The reach sampled is between Entrance, which is eight kilometers upstream from Hinton, and Windfall, which is at a distance of 175 km downstream. The measurements consisted of flow field, size distribution of in-situ and dispersed particles and concentration of particles in the water column. The data from the two surveys show that the pulp mill effluent has affected the physical transport characteristics of the ambient sediment. It promoted the flocculation of the incoming sediment particles and increased their deposition rates. During low river flow periods, when the ratio between the effluent discharge to flow discharge is the highest (about 4%), 74% of the incoming sediment deposited within 20 km from the outfall. During moderate flows (i.e., flows in the order of five times the winter flow) the deposition continued at a slower rate further downstream from the outfall. The results point to a need for an improved sediment transport model that considers the flocculation mechanism of the incoming sediment in the presence of pulp mill effluent. Existing models such as the one in WASP-4 will not predict sediment deposition downstream from the Weldwood Pulp Mill outfall and therefore are not suitable for making realistic predictions of pulp mill impacts in the Athabasca River.

Sludge storage at lease abandonment

Year of Publication: 1991

Abstract:
The large quantities of sludge and extraction tailings water contained in pondsat the closure of oil sands leases have been identified as significantenvironmental concerns, Tests have been conducted to assess changes in tailings pond water quality overtime. Biological, toxicological, chemical, and physical parameters have beenconsidered. Results indicate that the quality of top water in an abandoned pondmay be anticipated to Improve with time to an environmentally acceptablecondition. The rate of improvement can be manipulated utilizing known watertreatment technologies. The lake concept is an application of the information available on addressingthe sludge handling concerns in which the sludge is disposed of under a layerof reclaimed top water. A scheme for using the lake concept has been Incorporated Into a leaseabandonment plan for the Suncor oil sands project. The plan, which incorporatesexisting knowledge on sludge properties and dynamics, demonstrates a practical,environmentally sound approach for a facility which is in currentoperation.

SM 800 - Linear footprint and access management

Authors
Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
This report describes the outcomes and recommendations of a pilot sub-regional scale linear footprint and access management (LFAM) planning process. The process was funded by the Cumulative Effects Management Association with the intent to: 1. Provide LFAM recommendations agreeable to a broad representation of affected stakeholders that may be applicable to the RMWB region as a whole. 2. Inform the design and implementation of any future multi-stakeholder sub-regional planning processes undertaken as part of implementing the Lower Athabasca Regional Plan (LARP).

Small mammal populations of northeastern Alberta. I. Populations in natural habitats

Authors Green, J. E.
Year of Publication: 1980

Abstract:
A study of small mammal populations (small rodents and snowshoe hares), habitat use, small rodent diets, and small mammal damage in natural forest and successional communities was begun in June 1978 and continued until November 1979. Based on population sizes and distributions, four species of small mammals, Clethrionomys gapperi, Microtus pennsylvanicus, Peromyscus maniculatus, and Lepus americanus, were determined to be important components of the boreal forest ecosystem in northeastern Alberta. Twelve additional species of small mammals were captured during this program but numbers were small. Indices of habitat quality based on peak population sizes, responses to habitat structure, habitat preferences, an index of dispersal, reproductive activity, and nutritional condition indicated that balsam poplar forests and young successional areas were high quality habitats for most small rodents, whereas black spruce and tamarack forests were marginal. In contrast, black spruce communities were near-optimal habitats for L. americanus, and balsam poplar forests were only moderately well-suited. Feeding habits of C. gapperi, M. pennsylvanicus, and P. maniculatus in this study were similar to diets described previously in other studies. Lichens, Carex spp., and arthropods were the major foods for each species, respectively. Mycorrhiza were consumed regularly by all species. Bark tissue of trees and shrubs was found most frequently in C. gapperi diets, but was limited in diets of M. pennsylvanicus. Consumption of bark by P. maniculatus, previously unreported in the literature, was common during the spring and fall. Damage to trees and shrubs in natural and successional areas by small rodents was limited. In contrast, browsing by snowshoe hares was high in some communities, notably tamarack forests. Some species of trees and shrubs were highly susceptible to damage, whereas others were resistant. Some factors associated with local variation in amounts of small mammal damage are discussed.

Small mammal populations of northeastern Alberta. II. Populations in reclamation areas

Authors Green, J. E.
Year of Publication: 1980

Abstract:
A study of small rodent populations, habitat use, and amounts of small mammal damage to woody-stemmed plants on reclamation areas of Suncor Inc. lease was begun in July 1978 and continued until November 1979. Three species of small rodent were present in these areas; Microtus pennsylvanicus was the most abundant species followed by Peromyscus maniculatus and Clethrionomys gapperi. Microtus pennsylvanicus and P. maniculatus were captured in all study areas, whereas G. gapperi were captured only in an area dominated by natural regrowth of trees and shrubs. A number of other small mammal species such as Mustela erminea, Eutamias minimus, Microsorex hoyi, Sorex cinerius, and Phenacomys intermedius were captured in the reclamation study areas but numbers were extremely limited. Microtus pennsylvanicus and P. maniculatus populations in older reclamation areas were composed primarily of resident, breeding animals, whereas C. gapperi were only seasonally abundant. Microtus pennsylvanicus and P. maniculatus in new reclamation areas were mostly transient animals. Older reclamation areas with dense grass/legume cover appeared to provide highly suitable habitats for M. pennsylvanicus, moderately suitable habitats for P. maniculatus, and poor quality habitats for C. gapperi. New reclamation areas did not appears to provide suitable habitats for any of these three species. Aspects of habitat structure that were associated with small rodent abundance also are discussed. Small rodent damage to woody-stemmed plants was limited in all reclamation areas during 1978 and 1979. Amounts of damage were highest in older reclamation areas with dense grass/legume cover. The close association between grass cover and amounts of damage and between amounts of damage and numbers of M. pennsylvanicus suggests that the high numbers of M. pennsylvanicus in areas of dense grass cover may be associated with the high amounts of damage in these same sites.

Social impact assessment and the anthropology of the future in Canada's tar sands

Authors Westman, C. N.
Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
In considering risk forecasting in light of anthropological and interdisciplinary impact assessment literature, this article demonstrates that impact assessment in Canada's tar sands sector is about designing the future, legitimizing future energy development, and rendering defense of foraging economies into technical, rather than political, channels. Impact assessment is a future-oriented, modeling-based practice, with a problematic relationship to empirical research methods such as ethnography. While purportedly foregrounding the knowledge of expert forecasters over that of impacted people, impact assessment documents and processes actually raise serious questions about forecasters' expertise and impartiality. Using three case studies of traditional land use reports from the tar sands region, this article draws on literature from the Anthropology of the Future to understand and critique the construction of expert knowledge and predictive power in the tar sands region through social impact assessment documents.

Social media as a green virtual sphere: Examining the Alberta oil sands and the Northern Gateway Pipeline on Twitter

Authors White, B.
Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
Environmental issues are increasingly discussed through social media applications. Consequently, researchers are beginning to question whether social media could represent a green virtual sphere: a virtual public space to discuss environmental issues not governed by a single authority in which anyone can access; however, limited empirical research has been conducted to date. In response, this study combines text analysis, social network analysis, and semi-structured interviews to determine whether discussions regarding the Alberta oil sands and the Northern Gateway Pipeline on Twitter – a micro-blogging site – reflect the characteristics of a green virtual sphere. It was found that Twitter is used to disseminate information, access news, and engage in debate, but there are limitations: not everyone has access to Twitter, the government may monitor online activity, and discussions appear to be dominated by environmentalists and environmental organizations. Twitter use on these issues only partially reflects the characteristics of a green virtual sphere.

Socio-economic impact assessment: A strategy for planning

Authors
Year of Publication: 1977

Abstract:
Examines present socio-economic impact assessment methods, and presents a program to evaluate the socio-economic impact the Syncrude project has on the surrounding area.

Sodium free processing of oil sands ores: Toward total water management in mining operations

Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
Current water management strategies require recycling and reuse of oil sand process water (OSPW) as much as 80%. Continuous recycling and reuse of OSPW results in a degradation of the quality of water namely increases of total dissolved solids (TDS) and dissolved organic materials (DOM). This results in a net increase in operating and maintenance costs and an impact on extraction process and bitumen recovery. Remaining water containing fines and suspended clays adds to the mature fine tailings and associated problems for tailing ponds treatment and management. Presence of residual bitumen and other organics is known to create difficulties in common practices for flocculation and dewatering of tailings. With problems stated above, one may consider a pre-treatment approach in place of rather than the common post-treatment remedies. The ore grade profoundly affects the efficiency of bitumen recovery in the hot water extraction of bitumen which is a principal step in the current commercial technology for bitumen extraction in mining operations. Sodium hydroxide is often added to the conditioning step of the process and is needed to obtain higher bitumen recovery from most oil sand feeds. Use of NaOH, however, results in accumulation of sodium ions in recycled water, causing higher clay dispersion and producing tailings with poor geotechnical properties that turn into mature fine tailings. This is especially true for low grade and oxidized ores, which present the greatest challenges in bitumen recovery and produce the major portion of tailings. With current trends for increasing production from mining operations to almost double by 2020, industry has to adopt new technologies to manage tradeoffs between water and energy. We present a new approach toward total water management by introducing novel process aids for sodium-free processing of various oil sands ores. Lab experimental data were analyzed to evaluate the efficiency on the processability of low grade oil sands, water chemistry and tailing management. Our results demonstrate that the use of new process aids during the conditioning process leads to an improvement in bitumen recovery from low grade oil sands and can accelerate tailings settling resulting in better water management. The process aids were also used in combination of polymer flocculants to treat process tailings, resulting in better tailings dewatering and consolidation. This approach offers a potential chemical solution for total water management that can be incorporated into current ore processing facilities and to deliver boths some operational and economic benefits.

Soil and groundwater characteristics of saline sites supporting boreal mixedwood forests in northern Alberta

Year of Publication: 2010

Abstract:
The influence of salinity on boreal forest plants is of growing concern today because oil sands mining and other energy-related industrial activities in northern Alberta and elsewhere produce large areas of salt-affected soils that require reclamation and revegetation. We characterized soils (salinity, pH, and nutrient and moisture availabilities) and groundwater at six naturally saline sites in northern Alberta which were occupied by boreal mixedwood forests dominated by aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) and white spruce [Picea glauca (Moench) Voss]. Salinity increased with depth in the soil profile and decreased with distance away from adjacent non-forested saline wetlands. In areas where forest vegetation existed, the electrical conductivity (ECe) of the surface soil (0 20 cm depth) was always below 4 dS m 2; chemical properties of the lower subsurface soil (50 100 cm depth) and groundwater ranged well above what has been conventionally considered to be suitable for tree growth: ECe ranged from 4 to 23 dS m 2, sodium adsorption ratio ranged from 13 to 70, and the pH of some soil horizons was above 9.0. These sites had relatively high soil moisture and nutrient availabilities, and we hypothesize that these facilitate survival of forest vegetation on these sites, despite the high levels of salinity.

Soil and tree chemistry reflected the cumulative impact of acid deposition in Pinus banksiana and Populus tremuloides stands in the Athabasca oil sands region in western Canada

Authors Jung, K., & Chang S. X.
Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
The spatial variability of soil chemistry and Ca/Al ratios of soil solution and fine roots were investigated in jack pine (Pinus banksiana) and trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides, aspen) stands to assess the impact of chronic acid deposition on boreal forest ecosystems in the Athabasca oil sands region (AOSR) in Alberta, Canada. Available SO42− (as the sum of soluble and adsorbed SO42−) accumulated in the soil near tree boles of both species, reflecting the influence of canopy intercepted SO42−. In jack pine stands, pH and soluble base cation concentrations decreased towards tree boles due to increased SO42− leaching; the reverse was found in aspen stands due to deposition of base cations leached from the canopy. As a result, Ca/Al ratios in the soluble fraction in soils near jack pine boles were 5–20 times lower than that near aspen boles. The Ca/Al ratio did not reach the critical limits of 1.0 for soil solution (ranged from 1.0 to 4.1) or 0.5 for fine roots (0.7–7.9) in the studied watersheds. However, Aln+ concentrations in the soil solution ranged from 0.2 to 4.1 mg L−1 in NE7 and from 0.1 to 8.5 mg L−1 in SM8 that can inhibit the growth of white spruce (Picea glauca) seedlings that commonly succeed aspen in upland sites in the AOSR. We suggest that the spatial variation caused by tree canopies/stems will affect forest regeneration and the effect of acid deposition on forest succession in the AOSR should be further studied.

Soil and tree ring chemistry of Pinus banksiana and Populus tremuloides stands as indicators of changes in atmospheric environments in the oil sands region of Alberta, Canada

Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
The impact of chronic air pollution such as increased CO2 and NOx emissions on forest ecosystems in the Athabasca oil sands region in Alberta, Canada, was investigated in Pinus banksiana (jack pine) and Populus tremuloides (trembling aspen, aspen) stands in two watersheds (NE7 and SM8) located at different distances from the main emission sources of oil sands mining and upgrading facilities, using δ13C, δ15N, and Ca/Al of soil and tree ring samples as indicators. Watershed NE7 was exposed to greater amounts of acid deposition due to its closeness to the mining and upgrading area. The δ15N in the forest floor was lower (p < 0.05) in NE7 (ranged from −1.42 to −0.87‰) than in SM8 (−0.54 to 1.43‰), implying a greater amount of recent deposition of 15N-depleted N in NE7. Tree ring δ13C gradually decreased over time for both tree species/watersheds, indicating the influence of 13C-depleted CO2 emitted from industrial sources. Tree ring N concentration and δ15N were not different between watersheds and did not significantly change with time. Interestingly, however, the difference between watersheds (NE7–SM8) that is expressed as Diff_N (for N) increased with concomitant decreases in Diff_δ15N over time, implying greater increases in 15N-depleted N input in NE7 than in SM8. Such trends were stronger in aspen stands (R2 = 0.64 and p < 0.001 for Diff_N and R2 = 0.44 and p < 0.01 for Diff_δ15N between 1964 and 2009) than in jack pine stands. We conclude that δ15N in the forest floor and differences in N and δ15N of tree rings between watersheds are useful indicators reflecting the impact of spatial variations of air pollution on forest stands in the Athabasca oil sands region in western Canada.

Enter keywords or search terms and press Search

Search this site


Subscribe to the site

Syndicate content

Bookmark and Share