Skip To Content

Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography

The Cumulative Environmental Management Association (CEMA)partnered with the Oil Sands Research and Information Network (OSRIN) to create the new Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography, which includes documents relevant to the environmental management of oil sands development in Alberta. The majority of the documents focus on the mineable oil sands in the Athabasca deposit, though some documents relate to in-situ developments. This bibliography was last updated in November 2014.

Revegetation research: 1976 progress report. Sub-Projects VE 7.27.3 and 7.4

Authors
Year of Publication: 1977

Abstract:
Laboratory studies were conducted during 1976 to investigate native grasses and legumes potentially useful for revegetation on various soils. Plant growth was tested in various soils with and without the addition of fertilizer in the greenhouse and ill growth chambers. The Genera tested were: Agropyron Alopecurus, Bromus, Calamagrostis, Festuca, Phalaris, Phleum, Poa, Puccinellia, Astragalus, Hedysarum, Lupinus, Oxytropis, Glycyrrhiza, Lathyrus, Thermopsis, and Vicia. Field studies were conducted at Woodbend Station, Devon. Germination and early establishment were observed on unscarifled, fall-planted and scarified, spring-planted legumes. Work was begun at the Alberta Environment Research Station at Vegreville. Native grasses, naturalized grasses, agricultural varieties of grasses, and native and agricultural varieties of legumes were planted to be evaluated in the uniformity garden. Ft Fort McMurray, research areas were partly established on the Great Canadian Oil Sands Ltd. tailings dike site and the AOSERP Mildred Lake facility. The development of the seed production test sites at Peers, Waskatenau, and High Level were continued. Native species of legumes were seeded at the Peers legume seed-increase nursery. Native grass seed for plants which had been sown the previous year at four different sites in Alberta were harvested. The following tentative conclusions may be used for the planning of Future studies: (i) Plant growth can be established on tailings sand if there is adequate moisture present, but time of planting seems to be a critical factor in establishment; (ii) Native legumes can produce root nodules without the add1tion of inoculum, but capacity to produce nodules on tailings sand varies among species; (iii) Nutrient requirements and soil preferences of native species vary widely. However, it is difficult to establish plant growth on soils with a low pH, a high conductivity (i.e. high salt concentration), or, a high aluminum level; (iv) A high level of available fertilizer may wholly or partially inhibit germination of native legumes and some native grasses. The optimum concentration of fertiIizer is higher for plant growth than for seed germination in some native legumes, but the optimum is determined in part at least by the amount and type of amendment used to ameliorate the tailings sand; and (v) Amendment of tailings sand with silt may cause soil compaction and have subsequent adverse effects on the penetration of the cotyledons through the substrate. In sand amended with peat, the roots of the seedlings tend to remain in the amended layer. The optimum amount of amendment seems to depend to some extent on the species used.

Revegetation research: A progress report on work accomplished in 1975

Authors Vaartnou, H.
Year of Publication: 1976

Abstract:
This report outlines the progress made in 1975 in the Revegetation Research Program which is co-ordinated through the Botany Section of the Plant Industry Laboratory. This program is a joint research project co-sponsored by Alberta Agriculture, Alberta Environment, Alberta Highways and the Oil Sands Environmental Research Program. The program was initiated in 1973. That year a detailed provincial survey was done in regard to revegetative growth on newly disturbed areas. The major conclusion from the work of that year related to revegetation possibilities in unfavourable environments. The study showed that revegetation of moist, well drained areas appeared to be no real problem and could be accomplished using agronomic varieties now on the market. However, it became apparent that areas which are not so favourably endowed by nature would prove more difficult to revegetate. For these areas native species and naturalized landraces seemed to offer greater possibilities of success. This assumption was the initiating factor for the work done in 1974. In 1974 sites were selected throughout the province in order to test the growth possibilities of native species and naturalized landraces. These sites were selected in different areas of the province in an effort to obtain data on as many different micro-environments as possible. By the fall of 1974 34 test sites had been obtained and on 27 of these at least some planting had taken place. The detailed results of this work done in 1973 and 1974 are available in previous years reports. The work done in the summer of 1975 is a direct continuation of that of 1974. More small sites (see included map) were obtained and these also were planted with rows of test plants. We believe that by now there are sufficient sites throughout the province so that reasonable conclusions can be drawn for most areas in a few years time. The only areas in which additional sites are needed are the foothill and mountain areas, and very specialized sites such as Forestburg and Round Hills. Hopefully sites will be obtained in these areas and they will be planted in the future along with additional planting of native legumes and shrubs at current sites. In addition to the small sites larger areas have also been obtained to study the possibilities of seed increase of native ecotypes. These sites have also been outlined in this report. Included in this report is a short evaluation resume of the growth occurring at each site. In most cases the sites were evaluated twice during the course of the year. Very little growth was expected from those sites which were planted this year and this proved to be the case. Those sites which had substantial growth were evaluated for height and vigour. The height evaluation was done using standard techniques while the vigour rating was a subjective rating from 0 - 5, with 0 representing no growth at all above ground and 5 designating an excellent row. In the interest of brevity these results have not been detailed in full but the highlights for each site have been summarized. It must be emphasized that these are only first year results and conclusions must not be taken as applying with validity for long term extrapolation. Also each site must be taken as a separate entity and comparisons between sites are risky at best. The first tentative conclusions on these early test sites will be specified in two years time. In the summer of 1975 we were able, for the first time, to collect a reasonable amount of seed from native legumes and shrubs. This has been used to carry out the winter research in the laboratory and will also be used for limited field work in the spring. We expect that more seed from native legumes and shrubs will be needed to properly evaluate the ecotypic variability of various species and thus this seed will be collected in future years. Also, in 1975 the Plant Industry Division, Soil and Feed Testing Laboratory, analyzed the soil samples taken from each of the actual test sites. Consequently we are now able to relate the ecotypes involved to the overall environment and also to soil properties. This report also outlines the laboratory research which is underway at present. This research is being carried out in growth chambers and greenhouses supplied by Alberta Agriculture for this program. This laboratory work is reported in five sections: III Soil Analysis IV Seed Technology study V Testing of grasses on various soil types VI Testing of legumes on various soil types VII A study of the micro-organisms associated with seeds and seedlings. A report of the Preliminary vegetation survey of the Alberta Oil Sands Area - Bryophytes and Lichens conducted by Dr. P. W. Stringer is also included in this report. This survey was financed by money allocated for the AOSERP Empirical Revegetation Study.

Review and annotated bibliography of stream diversion and stream restoration techniques and associated effects on aquatic biota

Year of Publication: 1978

Abstract:
Stream diversion projects in the Alberta Oil Sands Environmental Research Program study area that have been or will be required in the course of oil sands development are outlined. The effects of stream diversions on aquatic life, natural recovery of stream ecosystems from the effects of diversion, effectiveness of habitat restoration or enhancement techniques, and potential applications of biomonitoring techniques for studying the effects of diversions are reviewed with special reference to the AOSERP study area. Scientific references pertaining to these topics are compiled in an annotated bibliography. Information \"gaps\" and research needs pertinent to the AOSERP study area are briefly outlined. The primary research need recommended at the present time is to collect as much information as possible about the effects of the Beaver Creek diversion to aid in planning future diversion projects and related programs of environmental research in the AOSERP study area.

Review and assessment of deposition and potential bioaccumulation of trace metals in the Athabasca oil sands region

Authors
Year of Publication: 2009

Abstract:
This technical report is to identify trace metals detected in various environmental media, compare the amount or concentration of the trace metals to environmental benchmarks and indicate the trace metals to be included in future evaluations.

Review and assessment of environmental effects information for wildlife and fish indicators in the Regional Sustainable Development Strategy (RSDS) study area within the Athabasca oil sands region (AOSR)

Year of Publication: 2003

Abstract:
This report summarizes reviewed literature on the observed responses of indicator species to environmental change and also attempts to estimate the relative susceptibility of indicator species to environmental change and effects induced by natural and anthropogenic events and activities.

Review and compilation of surface water research and reports for selected waterbodies in the Municipal District of Wood Buffalo

Authors
Year of Publication: 2002

Abstract:
Dillon Consulting was retained by the Water Working Group (WWG), under the auspices of the Cumulative Environmental Management Association (CEMA) to complete a literature review, assessment, and synopsis of existing surface water research and reports for selected water bodies in the Municipal District of Wood Buffalo. The report was not intended to provide a detailed statistical analysis of existing data.

Review of bioreactor designs applicable to oil sands process-affected water treatment

Authors Yu, T., & Ulrich A.
Year of Publication: 2014

Abstract:
The objectives of our research program were to: (1) study biological activities in oil sands mature fine tailings and oil sands process-affected water, (2) develop microbial biofilm seed to support engineered biological processes with enhancement measures, and (3) review available bioreactor technologies and select bioreactors for continuous operation in the next phase of the study. This report focuses on the literature review. A summary of the results of two M.Sc. theses focusing on objectives 1 and 2 of the research program are provided as an appendix to this report. Further information is available in the theses. We reviewed 89 papers (from 1980 to 2014) covering eight types of bioreactors with an emphasis on their performance in treating recalcitrant industrial wastewaters. Three types of reactors were selected for further analysis because they have been successfully developed and used for removal of refractory organic compounds from industrial wastewaters. They are moving-bed biofilm reactor, membrane bioreactor, and up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor. The literature review confirmed our initial understanding that in biodegradation of recalcitrant organic compounds, a successful strategy is to first employ an anaerobic bioreactor to break down primarily large molecular organic compounds, increasing their biodegradability, and then use an aerobic bioreactor for the biodegradable organic compounds. Biofilm, or aggregated microbial growth with mixed microbial populations including both anaerobic and aerobic species, is more effective in biodegradation of recalcitrant organic compounds and more resilient to survive in harsh environmental conditions. Based on the literature search, we have selected moving-bed biofilm reactor as the first reactor type for continuous operation. This type of bioreactor can support biofilm growth, can be operated under both anaerobic and aerobic conditions, has been tested on a variety of wastewaters, and has the advantages of low cost and ease of operation. The bioreactor system has been designed, fabricated, installed and tested. It is ready for continuous operation, pending funding for the next phase of continuous bioreactor operation. The selection of a second type of bioreactor with different configuration and superior performance is in progress.

Review of dispersion models and possible applications in the AOSERP study area

Authors Padro, J.
Year of Publication: 1979

Abstract:
At the request of the Meteorology and Air Quality Technical Research Committee of AOSERP, a literature survey of existing air quality models which may have possible applications in the air quality prognam of the AOSERP study area was conducted. In addition to reviewing the published literature, several private companies and governmental agencies with available models were contacted as were individuals working in the field. Models which are available for review are described in terms of their applicability, scientific rigor, advantages, and disadvantages. Models which can deal with complex terrain features are recommended in applications of air quality problems in the Alberta Oil Sands. A user's requirements survey was conducted in order to determine the extent to which existing models can meet the requirements of users. Since no single existing model can meet the requirements of all users, a hierarchy of models is recommended for air quality problems in the oil sands.

Review of flood stage frequency estimates for the City of Fort McMurray: Final report

Authors
Year of Publication: 1993

Abstract:
This study was undertaken for the Technical Committee, Canada-Alberta Flood Damage Reduction Program in response to concerns raised by the City of Fort McMurray over the validity of the elevation established in previous studies as representing the 1 in 100 year design flood level. The specific objectives were first, to examine the historic data and assess it reliability and second, to update the flood frequency analysis, incorporating additional data collected in recent years. The main conclusions arising from the study are: a) In spite of some limitations, the information available on the 1875 ice jam event and most other historic events is considered to be sufficiently reliable for inclusion in the flood frequency analysis, b) the 1 in 100 year break-up stage at Fort McMurray based on the updated frequency analysis is 250.0 m, and c) The estimated return period for the 1875 event is in the order of 350 years and corresponds to a flood stage 2.0 m above the 1 in 100 year stage. Designation of flood risk areas based on an historical flood that has exceeded the 1 in 100 year event is an option under the Flood Damage Reduction Program. However, given the extreme magnitude of the maximum historic event at Fort McMurray, it is felt to be unreasonable and inappropriate to designate to such a level. Instead, it is recommended that the updated 1 in 100 year breakup stage of 250.0 m be adopted as the design flood level for designation under the Flood Damage Reduction Program.

Review of four major environmental effects monitoring programs in the oil sands region

Year of Publication: 2010

Abstract:
There is a general lack of awareness of existing environmental effects monitoring programs for the mineable oil sands region. As a result, there is low public confidence in the nature and extent of the current environment health monitoring and reporting programs for the oil sands with respect to potential impacts of these developments on environmental and human health. The purpose of this study was to engage four main environmental effects monitoring and reporting organizations currently operating in the oil sands area to document their programs. Through an engagement and validation process, program information was tagged, inventoried and characterized. Each of these organizations is unique; they all play specialized roles in providing information, data and understanding of ecosystem effects. These organizations also provide vital monitoring information based on their media, or domain expertise that is essential to understanding the ecosystem health and human health of the oil sands area. The resultant information was captured and presented in the form of a one-page visual Summary of Environmental Effects Monitoring in the Oil Sands Area. Additional contextual information adds to the understanding of the current state and is presented as a Chronology of Environmental Effects Monitoring Activities (1990-2010). Detailed Fact Sheets are provided for each of the four monitoring programs: • Alberta Biodiversity Monitoring Institute (ABMI) • Cumulative Environmental Management Association (CEMA) • Regional Aquatic Monitoring Program (RAMP) • Wood Buffalo Environmental Association (WBEA) The report concludes by making some observations of the programs studied. The recommendations presented represent possible next steps to build on this body of work. The central observation and recommendation is that stakeholders, including the monitoring program staff themselves, lack a detailed understanding of the full suite of monitoring activities taking place in the oil sands area and in moving forward, a more integrated approach would benefit both the existing environmental effects monitoring programs and the ability to speak authoritatively about oil sands ecosystem effects as a whole.

Review of groundwater information associated with in situ recovery

Year of Publication: 1981

Abstract:
The Athabasca Oil Sands cover an area of approximately 36,000 km2 and contain an estimated 626 billion barrels of bitumen (approximately 100 billion m3) in place. Recovery of this bitumen will be undertaken by strip mining where the oil sands are covered by less than 100 m of overburden. The total reserves that can be removed by strip mining are in the order of 74 billion barrels (12 billion m3). This leaves an estimated 552 billion barrels (88 billion m3) of bitumen (88%) to be recovered by the in situ process. At the time of preparing this report there were three pilot plants operated by Amoco, Gulf, and Texaco. Because of the size of the reserves and the increasing need to develop domestic oil sources it appears that commercial development will increase significantly over the next few decades. Such massive-scale development could have substantial effect on the groundwater resources of the region. These changes could, in turn, impact on other environmental parameters. The purpose of this project was to document existing hydrogeological data, identify areas of concern and to outline a plan for monitoring changes in groundwater flow or quality.

Review of health effects of naphthenic acids: Data gaps and implications for understanding human health risk

Year of Publication: 2012

Abstract:
Oil sands mining involves removal of water from the Athabasca River basin in northeastern Alberta. Water produced during the extraction of bitumen from oil sands is referred to as oil sands process water (OSPW). Information on the likelihood of human exposure to OSPW derived naphthenic acids and toxicological (dose-response) data are needed to have a complete understanding of the human health risk of these compounds. A review of literature was undertaken as a first step in framing potential human health risk associated with exposure to OSPW-derived naphthenic acids in surface water. Specifically, this review focused on chemical characteristics of, and potential toxicological effects related to, OSPW derived naphthenic acids. General Chemical Characteristics of Naphthenic Acid Mixtures in OSPW There are several important findings of the review with regard to chemical characteristics of naphthenic acid mixtures in oil sand process waters: • OSPW represents a complex mixture of naphthenic acids along with other organic chemicals that can also contribute to potential toxicity of the mixture. • There is a difference in the distribution of organic compounds and their contribution to potential toxicity of OSPW that is fresh (i.e., OSPW recently produced from the oil sands extraction process) versus OSPW that is allowed to age (i.e., OSPW that has been aged for a number of years in inactive storage ponds or pit lakes). Aged OSPW contains higher molecular weight, multi ring naphthenic acids that have been shown to be more resistant to microbial degradation and less potent in toxicity to biological organisms. • An understanding of the forms and composition of OSPW derived naphthenic acids and other organic compounds present in fresh and aged OSPW, and the effect of aging and aging environment on this composition, and variation in OSPW composition across oil sands processes is incomplete. Human Exposure Evidence OSPW-derived naphthenic acids are not used by the human population and the potential for human exposure in the oil sands region will arise from their presence in surface water or from potential future release of reclaimed OSPW to surface water. Based on the information reviewed, it was found that: • Direct contact activities with surface water (e.g., ingestion and skin contact) represent a plausible way in which human exposure may occur to OSPW derived naphthenic acids. • Low water to air transfer properties and dilute concentrations of aged and reclaimed OSPW derived naphthenic acids provide no meaningful scientific evidence to support the inhalation pathway as being important for potential human exposure. • Low octanol water partition values and apparent rapid depuration of aged OSPW-derived naphthenic acids offer no meaningful scientific evidence to support the fish ingestion pathway as being important for potential human exposure to these compounds. Toxicological Evidence Toxicity information of interest for understanding human health risk from chemicals in the environment includes: acute toxicity, subchronic/chronic adverse responses (e.g., weight loss, immunosuppression, etc.), neurotoxicity, developmental and reproductive toxicity, and genetic toxicity (mutagenicity and carcinogenicity). A general finding of this review is: • Toxicological evidence observed for commercial naphthenic acids derived from crude oils and/or commercial naphthenic acid salts will not be representative of naphthenic acids in aged and reclaimed OSPW. Higher molecular weight, multi ring naphthenic acids, which are more resistant to microbial degradation and less potent in toxicity to biological organisms, are the forms reported to be present in aged and reclaimed OSPW. • OSPW derived naphthenic acids come from bitumen which is considered to be extensively biodegraded petroleum, whereas commercial naphthenic acids are typically prepared from petroleum sources that have not undergone extensive biodegradation. Therefore, potential human toxicity and corresponding human exposure limits for OSPW derived naphthenic acids should not be inferred from studies of commercial naphthenic acids. Acute Toxicity Naphthenic acids found within crude oils exhibit similar oral toxicity to table salt. Acute toxicity testing in rats revealed behavioral and histopathological effects from a single administration of OSPW derived naphthenic acids, but at a dosage 50 times a worst case environmental exposure for small mammalian wildlife. This dosage is a not realistic exposure condition that would apply to humans in the oil sands region. Subchronic/Chronic Noncarcinogenic Toxicity A finding of this review is: • Based upon limited information reviewed, uncertainty remains in the understanding of toxicokinetic (fate in the body) and toxicodynamic (mode of action and dose response) information needed to infer noncarcinogenic human exposure related responses to naphthenic acids and other acid-extractable organics present in aged and reclaimed OSPW. A recommendation of this review is: • There is a need to further examine potential subchronic/chronic toxicity of naphthenic acids and other acid-extractable organics present in aged and reclaimed OSPW. Developmental and Reproductive Toxicity A finding of this review is: • Based upon limited information reviewed, uncertainty remains about knowledge of developmental and reproductive toxicity of naphthenic acids and other acid-extractable organics present in aged and reclaimed OSPW. A recommendation of this review is: • There is a need to further examine developmental and reproductive toxicity endpoints of naphthenic acids and other acid-extractable organics present in aged and reclaimed OSPW using in vitro/in vivo bioassay testing focusing on cellular response pathways. Genetic Toxicity A finding of this review is: • Based upon limited information reviewed, uncertainty remains about knowledge of genetic toxicity of naphthenic acids and other acid-extractable organics present in aged and reclaimed OSPW. A recommendation of this review is: • There is a need to further examine genetic toxicity endpoints (including carcinogenic endpoints) of naphthenic acids and other acid-extractable organics present in aged and reclaimed OSPW using in vitro genetic (micronucleus) testing and/or other suitable tests focusing on cellular response pathways.

Review of linear footprint management approaches tools and strategies

Authors Porter, K., & Wilson B.
Year of Publication: 2011

Abstract:
The report was prepared to serve as a synthesis and summary of existing Sustainable Ecosystems Working Group (SEWG) work with respect to linear features, particularly the Terrestrial Ecosystems Management Framework (TEMF, 2008) and the Dialogue on Ecosystem Response Management System and Coordinated Access Management Strategies (2009), as well as relevant access/footprint management documents or work completed or underway elsewhere in Alberta and other jurisdictions. As well, the report identifies and assesses linear footprint management practices, tools, and strategies relevant to the RMWB, summarizes and synthesizes the key outcomes of the workshop and provides a detailed record of the dialogue during the workshop.

Review of mammal populations on lease No. 17 and vicinity

Authors
Year of Publication: 1979

Abstract:
Wildlife habitat on and in the vicinity of Lease 17 has been variously described by Syncrude Canada Ltd. (1973), Penner (1976) and others. Both Syncrude and Penner recognize 12 discrete habitat types however the reports differ considerably with respect to classification and characterization of habitat units. More recently, Peterson and Levinsohn (1977) provide an excellent description of seven major vegetation types present in the west half of Lease 17. Following is a brief review of the principal habitat units present on the lease prior to development, based mainly on the abovementioned reports and supported by a review of other pertinent references.

Review of odour management strategies

Authors Inc., O.
Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
The Air Working Group has identified three objectives related to the possible development of a regional odour management framework: 1. Better understand programs and activities related to odour management in the Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo and other jurisdictions on a regional scale involving multiple odour sources and types. 2. Understand the reporting and monitoring needs that would be necessary to support odour management strategies. 3. Recommendations on how these information needs could be met. CEMA contracted Odotech to provide a review of odour management strategies and information gaps as they may apply to the Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo. This review is provided in three parts: 1. Information review. 2. Assessment of odour management strategies. 3. Facilitation of an odour workshop and recommendations for odour management approaches that may be applicable to the Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo. This report summarizes these three parts. Chapter 2 presents the Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo and the type of emission sources. Chapter 3 and 4 present a brief review of odour management programs in Canadian provinces and in other developing countries respectively. Chapter 5 compares and discusses the effectiveness of the various odour management strategies. Chapter 6 focuses on the odour workshop and the results and recommendations.

Review of oil sands tailings pond contaminants with fish tainting potential

Year of Publication: 1986

Abstract:
The literature on tainting of fish by petroleum-derived compounds has been reviewed for information specifically relevant to the potential for tainting of fish in the Athabasca River. Major classes of compounds which are known to be present studied for fish in oil sands wastes and which have been uptake include: alkylated benzenes, alkylated naphthalenes, polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons, polynuclear aromatic sulphur heterocycles, polynuclear aromatic nitrogen heterocycles and naphthenic hydrocarbons. Threshold odor levels in water for many of these compounds occur in the 1-100 ppb range. A need for more background data on the occurrence of these types of compounds in the oil sands region and in oil sands effluents has been identified.

Enter keywords or search terms and press Search

Search this site


Subscribe to the site

Syndicate content

Bookmark and Share