Skip To Content

Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography

The Cumulative Environmental Management Association (CEMA)partnered with the Oil Sands Research and Information Network (OSRIN) to create the new Oil Sands Environmental Management Bibliography, which includes documents relevant to the environmental management of oil sands development in Alberta. The majority of the documents focus on the mineable oil sands in the Athabasca deposit, though some documents relate to in-situ developments. This bibliography was last updated in November 2014.

Comparison of geoenvironmental properties of caustic and noncaustic oil sands fine tailings

Authors Miller, W. G.
Year of Publication: 2010

Abstract:
A study was conducted to evaluate the properties and processes influencing the rate and magnitude of volume decrease and strength gain for oil sand fine tailings resulting from a change in bitumen extraction process (caustic versus non-caustic) and the effect of adding a coagulant to caustic fine tailings. Laboratory flume deposition tests were carried out with the objective to hydraulically deposit oil sand tailings and compare the effects of extraction processes on the nature of beach deposits in terms of geometry, particle size distribution, and density. A good correlation exists between flume deposition tests results using oil sand tailings and the various other tailings materials. These comparisons show the reliability and effectiveness of flume deposition tests in terms of establishing general relationships and can serve as a guide to predict beach slopes. Fine tailings were collected from the various flume tests and a comprehensive description of physical and chemical characteristics of the different fine tailings was carried out. The characteristics of the fine tailings is presented in terms of index properties, mineralogy, specific surface area, water chemistry, liquid limits, particle size distribution and structure. The influence of these fundamental properties on the compressibility, hydraulic conductivity and shear strength properties of the fine tailings was assessed. Fourteen two meter and one meter high standpipe tests were instrumented to monitor the rate and magnitude of self-weight consolidation of the different fine tailings materials. Consolidation tests using slurry consolidometers were carried out to determine consolidation properties, namely compressibility and hydraulic conductivity, as well as the effect of adding a coagulant (calcium sulphate [CaSO4]) to caustic fine tailings. The thixotropic strength of the fine tailings was examined by measuring shear strength over time using a vane shear apparatus. A difference in water chemistry during bitumen extraction was concluded to be the cause of substantial differences in particle size distributions and degree of dispersion of the comparable caustic and non-caustic fine tailings. The degree of dispersion was consistent with predictions for dispersed clays established by the sodium adsorption ratio (SAR) values for these materials. The biggest advantage of non-caustic fine tailings and treating caustic fine tailings with coagulant is an increased initial settlement rate and slightly increased hydraulic conductivity at higher void ratios. Thereafter, compressibility and hydraulic conductivity are governed by effective stress. The chemical characteristics of fine tailings (water chemistry, degree of dispersion) do not have a significant impact on their compressibility behaviour and have only a small influence at high void ratio (low effective stress). Fine tailings from a caustic based extraction process had relatively higher shear strengths than comparable non-caustic fine tailings at equivalent void ratios. However, shear strength differences were small and the overall impact on consolidation behaviour, which also depends on compressibility and hydraulic conductivity, is not expected to be significant.

Comparison of high- and low-resolution electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for the analysis of naphthenic acid mixtures in oil sands process water

Year of Publication: 2008

Abstract:
The oil sands regions of Northern Alberta, Canada, contain an estimated 1.7 trillion barrels of oil in the form of bitumen, representing the second largest deposit of crude oil in the world. A rapidly expanding industry extracts surface-mined bitumen using alkaline hot water, resulting in large volumes of oil sands process water (OSPW) that must be contained on site due to toxicity. The toxicity has largely been attributed to naphthenic acids (NAs), a complex mixture of naturally occurring aliphatic and (poly-)alicyclic carboxylic acids. Research has increasingly focused on the environmental fate and remediation of OSPW NAs, but an understanding of these processes necessitates an analytical method that can accurately characterize and quantify NA mixtures. Here we report results of an interlaboratory comparison for the analysis of pure commercial NAs and environmental OSPW NAs using direct injection electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and high-pressure liquid chromatography/high-resolution mass spectrometry (HPLC/HRMS). Both methods provided very similar characterization of pure commercial NA mixture; however, the m/z selectivity of HPLC/HRMS was essential to prevent substantial false-positive detections and misclassifications in OSPW NA mixtures. For a range of concentrations encompassing those found in OSPW (10–100 mg/L), both methods produced linear response, although concentrations of commercial NAs above 50 mg/L resulted in slight non-linearity by HPLC/HRMS. A three-fold lower response factor for total OSPW NAs by HPLC/HRMS was largely attributable to other organic compounds in the OSPW, including hydroxylated NAs, which may explain the substantial misclassification by ESI-MS. For the quantitative analysis of unknown OSPW samples, both methods yielded total NA concentrations that correlated with results from Fourier transform infrared (FTIR), but the coefficients of determination were not high. Quantification by either MS method should therefore be considered semi-quantitative at best, albeit either method has substantial value in environmental fate experiments where relative concentration changes are the desired endpoints rather than absolute concentrations.

Comparison of morphological and chemical characteristics of clay minerals in the primary froth and middlings from oil sands processing by high resolution transmission electron microscopy

Year of Publication: 2008

Abstract:
Understanding the interaction of clay minerals with bitumen in the oil sands is of great interest in developing water-free or water-reduced bitumen extraction processes. Previous work by Kaminsky et al. has shown, by x-ray diffraction, that there is a difference in clay minerals that partition to the froth stream versus the clays that remain in the middlings. However, x-ray diffraction analysis was insufficient in determining why the different minerals partitioned the way they did. This work examines the clay minerals in each stream by high resolution transmission electron microscopy, combined with energy dispersive x-ray analysis, to examine the characteristic chemical and morphological differences in the clay particles in each stream.

Comparison of the Ames Salmonella Assay and Mutatox Genotoxicity Assay for assessing the mutagenicity of polycyclic aromatic compounds in porewater from Athabasca oil sands mature fine tailings

Year of Publication: 1999

Abstract:
The oil sands in the Athabasca region of northeastern Alberta, Canada, represent a significant hydrocarbon resource that is currently exploited by mining, followed by separation of bitumen from sand using hot water flotation. This process generates large quantities of bitumen-contaminated tailings. Current research involves an assessment of whether the tailings ponds can ultimately be converted to biologically productive lakes, with one unresolved issue being the toxicity of the polycyclic aromatic compounds (PACs) that might be released from the tailings. In this paper, we have identified several polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the porewater from oil sands mature fine tailings and have compared the responses of 17 PACs in the Ames and Mutatox genotoxicity assays. The Mutatox assay was unsuitable as a surrogate for the Ames test in this application; poor (50%) concordance between the two assays occurred because the mechanism of light emission in the Mutatox assay is uncertain, leading to positive responses that could not be unambiguously associated with genotoxicity. Benzo[a]pyrene equivalency factors (BEFs) in the Ames assay were determined for a large number of PACs, from this work and from literature data, to express the genotoxic potencies of environmental mixtures in terms of benzo[a]pyrene equivalent concentrations (BEQs). In the case of porewater samples obtained from the mature fine tailings, even extracts concentrated 10,000-fold were below the detection limit of 1 μg/L BEQ, consistent with the value of 0.14 μg/L calculated using BEFs of PACs identified in the porewater.

Comparison of the structure and composition of cokes from the thermal cracking of Athabasca oil sands bitumen

Year of Publication: 1979

Abstract:
Three different cokes obtained from the thermal cracking of Athabasca Oil Sands bitumen by delayed coker, fluid coker and flexicoker processes have been compared in terms of their chemical composition (elemental analysis) and physical structure (scanning electron microscope). Flexicoker coke has been found to have the highest metal values and lowest heteroatom content of the three cokes, and has a unique porous structure. These features favour the lability of the metals in this coke and may account for its previously noted susceptibility to chemical leaching.

Compiling a geospatial database of existing oil sands industrial features for Alberta Environment

Year of Publication: 2010

Abstract:
As part of an on-going initiative to develop a clearer understanding of the impacts of oil sands development on the environment and support annual reporting processes, Alberta Environment initiated a project to create a Geospatial Database for Existing Oil Sands Industrial Features. This project included a range of landcover/land use assessments of surface disturbance and reclamation features in the 2000s, 1990s and 1980s. The primary objective of this project was to create a geospatial database of oil sands disturbance and reclamation features derived from recent (2007) and historical (1998 and 1985) data. The source data included satellite imagery, orthophotos, conservation and reclamation reports (CnR) submitted by oil sands operators, and a series of other ancillary GIS data supplied by Alberta Environment. The project employed the following steps: • First, 2007 oil sands CnR reports were examined and landform features were digitized from geo-referenced maps. The resulting data were used to refine an initial landcover classification of 2007 multi-spectral SPOT-5 imagery to create a final landcover/land use classification dataset. • Second, 1998 oil sands CnR were examined and landform features were extracted from geo-referenced maps for that year. The resulting dataset was again used to refine an initial landcover classification of Landsat-5 imagery from 1998 to create a final landcover/land use classification dataset. • Finally, 1985 oil sands historical documents were examined and landform features were extracted from orthophotos from the 1980s. As above, the resulting dataset was used to refine an initial landcover classification of Landsat-5 imagery from the 1980s to create a final landcover/land use classification dataset. The project deliverables included designing, building, and populating an ESRI ArcGIS file geodatabase with 2007, 1998 and 1985 satellite image mosaics, orthophotos, oil sands project boundaries, and derived landcover/land use feature datasets. Methodology documents were also completed for this project.

Composite tailings made from in-line thickened oil sands tailings

Year of Publication: 2010

Abstract:
An investigation of the use of in-line thickened tailings to create composite tailings at a sand to fines ratio, SFR, of 4:1 without any further chemical amendment is presented in this paper. At this SFR, it was found that the composite tailings made with in-line thickened tailings (ILTT-CT) had a static segregation point at 53% solids content and the composite tailings made with the parent material, cyclone overflow tailings (typical new fine tailings) without any additive, had a static segregation point at 59% solids content. The segregation boundary of the ILTT-CT with no added coagulant is comparable to that of the gypsum treated MFT-CT. It is also at a lower solids content, that is less susceptible to segregation, than the segregation boundary of old MFT-CT. ILTT-CT hydraulic conductivity is found to be controlled by the high hydraulic conductivity of the ILTT fines and the undrained shear strength of the ILTT-CT is considerably higher than that of the ILTT fines at the same fines void ratio. As well, as no coagulant is required, there is no detrimental effect to the reclaim water chemistry. The combination of faster consolidation and higher shear strength means that the ILTT-CT will be able to be reclaimed much earlier than MFT-CT. Judicial deposition techniques may result in it being reclaimed as it is being deposited.

Comprehensive analysis of oil sands processed water by direct-infusion Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry with and without offline UHPLC sample prefractionation

Year of Publication: 2013

Abstract:
Oil sands processed water (OSPW) is the main byproduct of the large-scale bitumen extraction activity in the Athabasca oil sands region (Alberta, Canada). We have investigated the acid-extractable fraction (AEF) of OSPW by extraction-only (EO) direct infusion (DI) negative-ion mode electrospray ionization (ESI) on a 12T-Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer (FTICR-MS), as well as by offline ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography (UHPLC) followed by DI-FTICR-MS. A preliminary offline UHPLC separation into 8 fractions using a reversed-phase C4 column led to approximately twice as many detected peaks and identified compounds (973 peaks versus 2231 peaks, of which 856 and 1734 peaks, respectively, could be assigned to chemical formulas based on accurate mass measurements). Conversion of these masses to the Kendrick mass scale allowed the straightforward recognition of homologues. Naphthenic (CnH2n+zO2) and oxy-naphthenic (CnH2n+zOx) acids represented the largest group of molecules with assigned formulas (64%), followed by sulfur-containing compounds (23%) and nitrogen-containing compounds (8%). Pooling of corresponding fractions from two consecutive offline UHPLC runs prior to MS analysis resulted in ~50% more assignments than a single injection, resulting in 3-fold increase of identifications compared to EO-DI-FTICR-MS using the same volume of starting material. Liquid-liquid extraction followed by offline UHPLC fractionation thus holds enormous potential for a more comprehensive profiling of OSPW, which may provide a deeper understanding of its chemical nature and environmental impact.

Comprehensive report on operational reclamation techniques in the mineable oil sands region

Year of Publication: 2008

Abstract:
This document is not intended to be used as a prescriptive manual for undertaking reclamation activities, but is intended to serve as a reference insofar as it describes what techniques and strategies have been used in the mineable Oil Sands, Mountain and Plains Coal mining regions (Figure 1.1). It also provides references to applicable legislation, regulatory approvals, annual reports, and relevant research and literature to guide the reader to more detailed and specific information.

Compromised development and survival in amphibians in reclaimed wetlands' water containing oil sands process-affected material (PO)

Authors Smits, J., & Schock D.
Year of Publication: 2011

Abstract:
When closing a mine, operators must comply with government regulations to ensure that the sites are ecologically sustainable to support endemic flora and fauna. Creating wetlands in order to age and detoxify oil sands process-affected materials (OSPM) is a common reclamation strategy. In this study, amphibians indigenous to the boreal forest ecosystem were examined to determine if they can complete their lifecycle in water from reclaimed wetlands. Wood frog (Lithobates sylvaticus) eggs were collected from a natural pond 60 km south of an oil sand mining site. Tadpoles were raised in 1 of 6 water treatments refreshed every two days. The 2 reference water treatments included aged tap water and water from natural wetlands. The remaining 4 water treatments were from research wetlands on Syncrude and Suncor lease sites. Of the 120 tadpoles raised per water treatment, there was no significant difference in growth, development, or survival rates between the aged tap water and reference wetland water, but the fastest growth, development, and highest survival rates occurred in the two reference groups. There was a pronounced difference among the 4 treatment groups from Suncor and Syncrude reclamation sites. Survival was high in 3 of the water treatments from Syncrude and Suncor sites, but development rates were considerably reduced. Tadpoles that do not metamorphose before winter do not survive. It was therefore concluded that delayed development in tadpoles poses a serious risk to population stability in OSPM-containing wetlands.

Compromised metamorphosis and thyroid hormone changes in wood frogs (Lithobates sylvaticus) raised on reclaimed wetlands on the Athabasca oil sands

Year of Publication: 2011

Abstract:
The wet landscape approach to oil sands tailings reclamation in the Athabasca Oil Sands region involves creating wetlands from fluid tailings in mined-out pits. We measured time to metamorphosis, thyroid hormone status, and detoxification enzyme (EROD) induction in Wood frog (Lithobates sylvaticus) tadpoles raised on reclaimed oil sands wetlands of different ages [young (≤ 7 yr) vs. old (> 7 yr)] and compared data with tadpoles raised on reference (control) wetlands. Metamorphosis was delayed or never occurred in tadpoles raised in young tailings; those exposed to older tailings developed similarly to those in reference wetlands. Thyroid hormone disruption likely played an important role in the metamorphosis delay as the T3:T4 ratio was lowest in tadpoles raised in young, tailings-affected wetlands. Our findings suggest tailings wetlands become less toxic with age, and that these amphibians will be able to complete their life cycle in tailing wetlands that have sufficiently detoxified with age.

Computational fluid dynamics modeling of deposition of oil sand slurry into mature fine tailings

Authors Yang, J.
Year of Publication: 2009

Abstract:
The objective of this research program is to study the feasibility of using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) approach to the modeling of dense slurry flow with a special emphasis on oil sand slurry inflow into oil sands mature fine tailings (MFT). An experimental program is established to measure the viscosity and the yield stress of the slurry with various solids and fines contents. The viscosity and yield stress of the slurry are curve fitted using Power Law model and Herschel-Bulkley model. Then the flow curve for pure MFT is applied in the CFD simulation of the viscosity and yield stress measurements using the single phase model in CFX-10. The simulated torques reasonably agree with those from experiments. Sedimentation process for bidisperse and polydisperse suspension from literature are simulated using MFIX and FLUENT. Simulation results indicate that the Euler-Euler Model in those two CFD packages is capable of modeling the sedimentation process of the bidisperse and polydisperse suspension. Then the settling process of the segregating and non-segregating oil sand tailing slurry is selected to test the capability of MFIX, FLUENT-6 and CFX-10. The results show that the transient process of the sedimentation, therefore the segregation, of the tailing slurry can not be captured by those models if the viscosity of the water phase is not changed to reflect the interaction between clay particles and the water phase.

Concentrations of metallothionein in fish Peace Athabasca and Slave River basins September to December 1994

Year of Publication: 1996

Abstract:
Fish from Peace, Athabasca and Slave rivers and their tributaries are exposed to a variety of pulp mill, municipal and industrial effluents (EnviResource 1995; Brown and Vandenbyllaardt, 1996). Assessments of effects of contaminants have focussed on chlorinated organic compounds, such as dioxins and furans (Pastershank and Muir, 1995), and on alterations of parameters affecting reproduction physiology in individual fish (Brown et al., 1993; Brown et al., 1996; Lockhart et al., 1996). These studies have demonstrated that there is exposure to organic contaminants because mixed function oxidase activities are elevated (Lockhart, et al., 1996; Lockhart and Metner, 1996); and that fish collected downstream from the pulp mills may be stressed, because they exhibit a high percentage of sexually immature individuals, and they have depressed circulating concentrations of gonadal steroid hormones (Brown et al., 1993; Brown et al., 1996). The purpose of the research described in this report was to initiate studies to see if metals may be contibuting to these stresses. The objective was to evaluate whether the metal-binding protein, metallothionein, was elevated in organs of burbot, longnose sucker, northern pike or flathead chub collected downstream from pulp mills and other effluent discharge points, and whether there was evidence of cumulative impacts with progression downstream in these rivers. An increase in MT concentrations in fish represents a molecular response that generally indicates exposure and development of resistance to toxicity to metals, especially Cd, Cu, Hg and Zn (Klaverkamp et al. 1991; Roesijadi, 1992). The study was designed by the Northern River Basins Study Science Directors and the Contaminants Component Leader, and was based on selecting fish collection sites on their proximity to discharges from pulp mills. Additional information on fish collection sites and on general biological parameters of fish collected in 1994 is presented in other reports (EnviResource 1995; Brown et al. 1996). Two observations were made, both in burbot, which may indicate exposure to elevated metal concentrations and the presence of cumulative impacts. First, the greatest difference in MT concentrations between collection sites was observed in kidney of burbot collected in the Slave River Delta (SRD) of Great Slave lake. MT concentrations in kidneys from these fish ranged from approximately 7-times to 26-times higher than those concentrations found in kidneys of burbot from other collection sites. MT concentrations in gill of burbot from SRD were also the highest observed. The SRD burbot may be exposed to metals due to natural conditions of high mineralization in the Great Slave Lake Delta or other parts of the lake; or these fish may be exposed to metals discharged by mining operations, such as the decommissioned lead-zinc mine at Pine Point. The counterclockwise current in this portion of the lake could transport metals from a western source, such as Pine Point, to the Slave Delta (English, 1984). Second, a progressive increase in MT concentration in proceeding from upstream fish collection sites to downstream sites was observed in concentrations of MT in burbot liver. In the Peace River and associated tributaries (Little Smoky, Smoky, and Wapiti), there is a progressive increase of up to 3.34-fold in burbot liver [MT] moving from upstream to downstream collection sites. In the upper Athabasca River system, there is a progressive increase of up to 2.33-fold in burbot liver [MT] moving from upstream to downstream collection sites.

Conceptualizing water movement in the Boreal Plains: Implications for watershed reconstruction

Year of Publication: 2012

Abstract:
The aim of this document is to provide guidance on landscape reconstruction based on the results of more than a decade of research in natural forest systems on the Boreal Plains. It is hoped that the synthesis will prove useful to a range of audiences – from general readers interested in the broader concepts and implications of the research to practitioners who require technical details on designing a landscape or directing day-to-day reclamation operations in the field. The document can be grouped into five main sections. Section A, the Executive Summary, is the highest-level synthesis of the conceptual model. It contains the key learnings from the research and their overarching implications for landscape reconstruction. Section B provides the research context: a brief history of the research, focal questions, and locations and descriptions of the study sites. Section C provides a synthesis of the core concepts on which the new conceptual model of water flow in the Boreal Plains has been developed. Section C.1 introduces the structure of the body of the document, which pivots around the hydrologic context, composition, and connectivity, and the water balance as discussed in the Executive Summary. Section C.2 summarizes the basic concepts and key principles and develops the core of the conceptual model. In general, Section C provides the fundamental basis required to develop plans and understand water flow in these landscapes using this new conceptual model. Section D describes the details of key components of the landscape. This section fleshes out the underpinnings of the basic concepts and provides details of landscape features. Section E provides examples of how to approach a water balance in these landscapes, some key numbers that can be used to guide the landscape practitioner, a summary of how the information can be used in landscape reconstruction, and some outstanding research needs. This section relies heavily on the details described in Sections C and D. One core concept arising from the research is that in landscapes there are repeating hydrologic elements and processes that occur at all scales. Therefore, one has to telescope up and down continually to understand the hydrologic behaviour observed at the various scales. Similarly, important concepts and connections run through the document and reappear in numerous sections. Therefore, for the person who reads through the document from beginning to end, repetition of these key ideas in each section will be obvious. The reader will also note that each section of the document contains a summary of key concepts from the research in natural systems. The implications of these key concepts for landscape reconstruction are reported at the end of each section. This approach is meant to illustrate, as clearly as possible, how the authors arrived at their recommendations for landscape reconstruction based on research predominantly conducted in natural boreal systems. The statements in the body of the document are based on evidence/data collected over a decade of research, most of which may be found in published papers, listed in Section F. The implications for landscape reconstruction are suggestions for consideration, based on the research findings.

Concurrent low flows in the Athabasca River basin

Year of Publication: 1989

Abstract:
A hydrologic parameter that has become synonymous with water. qua 1ity eva 1uati ons of ri vers is the term 117Q101l. Thi s term represents the annual minimum 7-day discharge at a particular location along a river, below which flows would be expected to occur in only 10% of the years. The complement to this definition is that there is a 90% chance in any year that the average 7-day flow would never be less than the 7Q10 value. Areal variability in climatic and physiographic parameters throughout the Athabasca River basin produces a number of possible low flow scenarios. The question is then: what is the likely flow at one 1ocation if the flow at another is known to be the 7Q10 flow? The statistical analysis that answers this question is called conditional probability. It is an approach whereby the distribution of flow at one location is mathematically related to flow at another. Scena r; os of expected concurrent flow along the Athabasca River are developed on the assumption that a 7Q10 event occurs at either Hinton, Whitecourt, Athabasca, or Fort McMurray. While expected flows represent the most probable situations, it is possible that a 7Q10 event can occur from a totally different flow pattern than expected. The likelihood of these other scenarios is outlined where appropriate. Both annual and open water scenarios are provided. A number of interesting flow patterns are evident. The premise that low flow events throughout the Athabasca Ri ver bas i n cannot be treated as independent events is confirmed. In the annual flow case, concurrent 7Q10 flows can span the reach from the Lesser Slave River to Lake Athabasca. In the open water case, there is a reasonable chance that concurrent low flows could extend from Whitecourt to Athabasca or from Athabasca to Fort All scena ri os poi nt to the value in basin-wide assessments of low flow.

Enter keywords or search terms and press Search

Search this site


Subscribe to the site

Syndicate content

Bookmark and Share